Archive for September, 2010

September 20, 2010

On SPEAK (Or, why controversy works)

I don’t have much to add to the conversation/backlash circulating in response to professor Weseley Scroggin’s call to ban several books (Slaughterhouse Five by Kurt Vonnegut, Speak by Laurie Halse-Anderson, and Twenty Boy Summer by Sarah Ockler) from his school district’s reading list. Like pretty much everyone else, I am 100% against banning books (because I’ve read Fahrenheit 451 and studied the Nazis, among other reasons), and I am in favor of parents deciding what their children should or should not read in school.

Of the three, I’ve read only Speak and I thought it was a raw, powerful look at rape and its consequences. I know how it has profoundly impacted several of my friends who have been sexually assaulted, and given them the courage to speak out about their situations and give a voice to the voiceless. Ban that? Hell no.

Here are a few posts I’ve ran across today that have really struck home with me about this whole thing:

As Told by Jen: Speak Loudly
Veronica Roth: A Christian Take on Banning Speak
KellyVision: Coming Out Again
The Last Word: SPEAKing Out
My Friend Amy: A Few Words on Rape As Porn
Sassymonkey Reads: Speak is Not Pornography

But really I wanted to touch on the fact of how overwhelmingly blessed we are to be able to have this conversation at all. If we follow down the path that starts with banning books, it doesn’t take long to get to the banning of other things — blogs, television shows, freedom of movement, human rights…

…Jews.

Yet as angry as his statement makes us, I fully support Scroggins’ first-amendment right to say what he said. Just as I fully support my right and everyone else’s to call him an idiot.

And how many more books are Vonnegut, Halse-Anderson, and Ockler going to sell now (Ockler’s book, which I just put on hold at the library, already has a dozen holds on it)? How many more people are going to read them and be impacted by them because of his stupid statement. Countless.

Oh, the power of freedom.

September 14, 2010

Buried (Or, In the Land of ARCs)

For a while, I’ve been receiving ARCs and review copies from publishers for me to review. Which, let’s all agree, is freakin’ awesome. *claps for the publishers*

But my ARCs and review copies are starting to pile up. Some of them I’ve loved and decided to keep, others I’m okay parting with for others to enjoy.

So, book blogging friends, tell me — what is proper ARC/review copy ettiquite? I know that it’s not ethical to sell or trade them, but what are my other options? Am I okay to do giveaways for ARCs and review copies? Give them to libraries or Goodwill? Rocket them into outer space?

Kelly said she puts in her review policy that she will use ARCs and review copies as giveaways, unless specifically prohibited. This seems wise. What do the rest of you do?

Thanks in advance!

September 14, 2010

#63 – Amy Inspired by Bethany Pierce

Amy Inspired by Bethany Pierce

Read: as a review copy from LibraryThing Early Reviewers (Bethany House, 340 pages, to be published October 1, 2010)

Rating: 7 out of 10 (finished 9/13/10)

Synopsis: Amy Gallagher is an aspiring writer who, after countless rejections, has settled for a career as an English professor in small-town Ohio just to pay the bills. All her dreams suddenly start to unravel as rejections pile up–both from publishers and her boyfriend. But just as Amy fears her life is stuck in a holding pattern, she meets the mysterious, attractive, and unavailable Eli. She struggles to walk the fine line between friendship and something more with Eli, even as staying true to her faith becomes unexpectedly complicated. When secrets, tragedy, and poor decisions cause rifts in Amy’s relationships, she must come to terms with who she’s become, her unrealized aspirations for her life, and the state of her faith. Can she dare to hope that she will find love and fulfillment despite it all?

Overall Impression: I don’t read a ton of Christian fiction, and when I do it strays more toward the Ted Dekkers’ of the writing world. I’ll admit it — I’m usually put off by the pastel covers and the soft focus faces of Christian romance, which means, as many of my blogging friends might tell me, that I’ve probably missed a lot of good books. There was a quality discussion in the book blogging world sometime in the last six months about the face of Christian fiction, and how many readers judge books by their covers — sometimes for better, but usually for worse. For me, it was reading some gag-worthy Christian fiction when I first became a Christian twelve years ago that turned me off to the genre altogether. I’m just now getting my feet wet.

Thankfully, Amy Inspired stays away from the more insipid, cloying writing that Christian romance can sometimes fall victim to. It didn’t take much for me to get into it, and I enjoyed it all the way through, although it did stray into just-a-little-too-perfect toward the end. I related to Amy — she’s 29 (me too), an aspiring writer (er…I aspire to be an aspiring writer), she feels a little stuck (me too), and she had to deal with her younger brother getting married (me too), a friend’s parent passing away (me too), and a quirky mother (me too…but in the best way possible!). I liked her roommate and her love interest, although the scary-future-mother in me kept thinking, “I’m not sure I’d let him date my daughter!” (make sure you say that in a slightly higher-than-normal, on-the-edge-of-sanity sort of way) The plot was lazy and familiar, but it clipped right along without dragging. I read the majority of it in less than twenty-four hours.

Pros: Relatable characters, faith elements without being preachy, nothing that made me want to barf.

Cons: Amy seems to get sick/injured one too many times, a pat ending, and some of the metaphors felt forced.

Other books I’ve read by Bethany Pierce: none, but I’d like to read her novel Feeling for Bones.

Other blogger opinions: It’s Just Me Wendy and Love 2 Read Novels

Legal gobbledygook: I received this book free from LibraryThing as part of their Early Reviewers program.  The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

September 10, 2010

#62 – Outlive Your Life by Max Lucado

Outlive Your Life by Max Lucado

Read: as a review copy from BookSneeze (Thomas Nelson, 240 pages, will be published September 14, 2010)

Rating: 7 out of 10 (finished 9/10/10)

Synopsis: These are difficult days in our world’s history. 1.75 billion people are desperately poor, natural disasters are gouging entire nations, and economic uncertainty still reigns across the globe. But you and I have been given an opportunity to make a big difference. What if we did? What if we rocked the world with hope? Infiltrated all corners with God’s love and life? We are created by a great God to do great works. He invites us to outlive our lives, not just in heaven, but here on earth. Let’s live our lives in such a way that the world will be glad we did.

Overall Impression: This book reminded me a little of Looking for God by Nancy Ortberg. The subject matter is somewhat different (Ortberg encouraged looking for God in the little things, while Lucado asks us to consider how we can serve Jesus in the world through the things we do), but they have the same conversational flowing tone. The authors use a similar cadence as well — long lines punctuated by short, staccato sentences. It’s all very readable.

Lucado takes the reader through the book of Acts, in an effort to call us to a higher form of living that is based in the love of Christ. Because of that love, we should be more loving to those around us — by feeding the poor, caring for the orphans, visiting those in prison, and comforting the widow. It was Jesus’ primary focus, and it should be ours as well. And I agree with Lucado — if we stopped thinking about ourselves so much and made an effort to love people more, we really could make a difference in the world. Imagine that — Christians behaving like Christians. It shouldn’t be as revolutionary as it sounds.

I also loved the little prayers that are added between the chapters. It really caused me to stop and pray and think about what Lucado was focusing on in each chapter. At the end of the book were discussion questions, and I realized that this would make an excellent Bible study book. In fact, I think it would be better that way — to discuss each chapter with other Christians, and to work together to find ways to outlive our lives.

Pros: Another great book to encourage a little less selfishness in our lives.

Cons: Would have been better to have read it in a Bible study, and to have the accountability of other Christians who also want to change the way they interact with the world.

Extras: Join Lucado on Facebook, follow Lucado on Twitter, and visit Lucado’s website

Other books I’ve read by Max Lucado: He Chose the Nails

Other blogger reviews: none — did you review this? I’ll link you!

Legal gobbledygook: I received this book free from Thomas Nelson as part of their BookSneeze program.  The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

September 10, 2010

#61 – Unfinished Business by Lee Kravitz

Unfinished Business by Lee Kravitz

Read: as a review copy from Library Thing Early Reviewers (Bloomsbury, 224 pages, originally published June 2010)

Rating: 5 out of 10 (finished 9/7/10)

Synopsis: After losing his job, Lee Kravitz, a workaholic in his midfifties, took stock of his life and realized just how disconnected he had become from the people who mattered most to him. He committed an entire year to reconnecting with them and making amends. Kravitz takes readers on ten transformational journeys, among them repaying a thirty-year-old debt, making a long-overdue condolence call, finding an abandoned relative, and fulfilling a forgotten promise. In each instance, the act of reaching out opens new paths for both personal and spiritual growth. All of us have unfinished business — the things we should have done but just let slip. Kravitz’s story reveals that the things we’ve avoided are exactly those that have the power to transform, enrich, enlarge, and even complete us.

Overall Impression: Well, I loved the idea of sorting out things that have been weighing on you for years; things that you know you should have dealt with or changed, but that you never got around to. We all have stuff like this — there was a boy that was teased mercilessly in elementary school, and I threw my share of verbal stones in his direction. To this day, I feel absolutely wretched when I think about what this poor kid endured. I’ve tried finding him on FB, but he doesn’t seem to be on there, which actually worries me. I wish I could find him and tell him that I’m so sorry for any pain I may have caused him.

Anyway, Kravitz decides to hunt down people he has unfinished business with. He’s lucky, however, in that he has the time, money, and support to travel around the country finishing things up. It felt a little unfair — how are the rest of us supposed to do these sorts of things when we have jobs and families and responsibilities? And many of the visits he made to people felt a little self-indulgent — like the stories were too much about him and not enough about the other person sometimes. For instance, he promised an African boy he’d help build a library in his refugee camp, but nothing really came of it – his family decided to see if they could send a box of books over there, but you never find out if they do it. It was sort of I-wanted-to-do-this-and-now-here’s-something-to-make-me-feel-mildly-better-about-reneging-on-a-promise-to-a-starving-child…

But it was still interesting to see him attempt to reconcile different parts of his past with his current life. I particularly liked the chapter about getting his dad and uncle on speaking terms again. For him to discover things about his father he never knew was quite beautiful.

Pros: A really great idea, and one that we should all consider. Are things from our past weighing us down when it would only take a little bit of “finishing” to get whatever it is off our shoulders?

Cons: Felt a bit repetitive in places (visit after visit after visit) and sometimes his essays felt too self-centered (granted…it is a memoir!).

Other books I’ve read by Lee Kravitz: none

Other blogger reviews: Book a Week with Jen and Lesa’s Book Critiques

Legal gobbledygook: I received this book free from LibraryThing as part of their Early Reviewers program.  The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 784 other followers