Posts tagged ‘dailylit’

March 8, 2012

Book Review: #13 – Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw

Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw

Source: DailyLit.com
Finished: 2/27/12
Rating: 7 out of 10
Publisher: Dover Publications
Pages: 96
Published: 1912
Challenges: 2012 Back to the Classics Challenge

Synopsis (from Wikipedia): Professor of phonetics Henry Higgins makes a bet that he can train a bedraggled Cockney flower girl, Eliza Doolittle, to pass for a duchess at an ambassador’s garden party by teaching her to assume a veneer of gentility, the most important element of which, he believes, is impeccable speech. The play is a sharp lampoon of the rigid British class system of the day and a comment on women’s independence, packaged as a romantic comedy.

* * * This review contains spoilers about the end of Pygmalion
(which is different than the end of My Fair Lady) * * * 

Overall Impression: Way back when, we studied the original Greek myth of Pygmalion, where the sculptor finds his statue so beautiful that he falls in love with it. Aphrodite hears his prayers and turns the statue into a real woman, and they live happily every after. Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw is the playwright’s own take on this classic myth.

The play itself is not familiar only because of the Greek myth, but also because it was adapted into the film My Fair Lady, starring Audrey Hepburn and Rex Harrison. Perhaps you have heard of it.

The play itself is very entertaining (probably more entertaining on stage than it is on paper), with witty banter and sharp dialogue all the way through. Eliza is ever the proud Cockney flower girl, even after she’s been turned into a lady. Henry is…an asshat. He might be the most clueless man in literature. I found his lack of growth as a character disturbing, but I also realize that Shaw is making some razor-sharp satire, and it doesn’t work if Henry changes his ways.

Most people would assume (based on the original myth and My Fair Lady) that Eliza and Henry end up married, but they do not. Shaw made the choice of having Eliza marry Freddy, and then offers an extra part (not part of the play) explaining his motives behind not having Eliza and Henry end up together. While I thought this to be an awkward addition (I didn’t realize I’d moved from play to explanation and I was confused at what was happening), it really made Shaw’s point that there’s no way that Eliza could have been happy with her creator.

Positives: Entertaining dialogue. A sharp commentary on what society makes of us.

Negatives: I felt…meh at the end. I think we’ve been so conditioned to happy endings that we’re a little shocked when they aren’t handed to us on a silver platter.

Other books I’ve read by George Bernard Shaw: none

Other blogger opinions:

Broke and Bookish: “I could see in my head some of the cues onstage and how well they would work.”

A Guy’s Moleskine Notebook: “This play is a lovely satire that directs to high society’s snobbery and willful ignorance.”

A Hoyden’s Look at Literature: “The play itself is a quick read, especially since most of the scenes are familiar from My Fair Lady.”

Mini Review of My Fair Lady

I had watched My Fair Lady way back when I was a kid, and apparently I didn’t have many memories of it since much of it felt brand new. This time, I thoroughly enjoyed the production. The songs were a particularly wonderful addition (I could have danced all night…). Hepburn was over-the-top as Eliza (how is she so pretty covered in dirt?), and Harrison was a slightly less asshatty Henry than the Henry in the original play. The ending, of course, has Eliza and Henry working through their difficulties and finding they truly love each other after all.

November 14, 2011

Book Review: #98 – The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton

Note: You may (or may not) notice that I am skipping around in my book reviews these days. I’ve finished several books as a judge for the INSPYs, but those reviews won’t be published until after the winners have been announced in December. There will also be a post of snippet reviews at the end of the month.

The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton

Source: DailyLit.com
Finished: 11/11/11
Rating: 7 out of 10
Publisher: Dover Publications
Pages: 240
Published: 1920

Synopsis (from Amazon): Wharton’s story of the upper classes of Old New York, and Newland Archer’s impossible love for the disgraced Countess Olenska, is a perfectly wrought book about an era when upper-class culture in this country was still a mixture of American and European extracts, and when “society” had rules as rigid as any in history.

Overall Impression: This book made me depressed. For a while, I couldn’t figure out why I just was not getting into it like some of the other reviewers, and I realized that I felt both stifled and sad at the lives that all the characters lead — which was probably one of Wharton’s main points. It made it difficult for me to want to keep reading. Why immerse myself in their world when I found it so downright miserable?

But while I didn’t necessarily enjoy reading it a lot of the time, there were a lot of things that I thought Wharton did very well. First was put the entire New York social system on display, pointing out its inconsistencies and foibles. Even though it was written more than 90 years ago, I thought that the way that the characters behaved according to their customs mirrored some of our societal groups today (for some reason it made me think of certain church people, who run around in cliques and judge other people while thinking themselves holy). While I don’t want to condone any sort of extra-marital affair, I could understand why Archer felt so stifled in his marriage and sought out the companionship and love of Countess Olenska. But really, it was a book of setting aside all of your wants and desires and doing your duty — and living with the decisions you have made — no matter how much it may hurt you. The best part of the book for me was the ending — I thought that it was perfectly done.

Positives: Solid writing, deep characters, and a very astute look at a culture that would rather not be inspected too closely.

Negatives: I sort of want to jump out of a window now.

Other books I’ve read by Edith Wharton: none

Other blogger opinions:

Literary Musings: “I think this is a story about a life of regret. I think this is a novel that articulates the importance of timing in life and the mutability of of our everyday world. It’s about doing what’s best for those you care about and stifling selfish motivations.”

Books and Movies: “It’s not very often that I would consider a classic a page-turner (aside from maybe Austen’s works), but this book was very hard to put down.”

The Novel World: “Edith Wharton’s classic is much like Pride and Prejudice; filled with social commentary and distaste for elitist norms and customs. It did, however, lack the wit and humor that made Pride and Prejudice a fun read.”

September 20, 2011

Book Review: #78 – Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen

Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen

Source: DailyLit (I also have a personal copy)
Read: It was the last of Austen’s novels I’d had yet to read
Finished: 9/14/11
Rating: 9 out of 10
Publisher: Dover Publications
Pages: 208
Published: 1814

Synopsis (from Amazon)Catherine Morland grows up to be a passably pretty girl and is invited to spend a few weeks in Bath with a family friend. While there she meets Henry Tilney and his sister Eleanor, who invite her to visit their family estate, Northanger Abbey. Once there, Austen amuses herself and us as Catherine, a great reader of Gothic romances, allows her imagination to run wild, finding dreadful portents in the most wonderfully prosaic events.  

Overall Impression: It’s a sad day when you get to the end of Jane Austen’s novels. (Thank goodness she’s so re-readable!) Northanger Abbey was Austen’s final novel for me. *sad face*

I really loved this little novel. It’s a (rather cute) satire of the Gothic literature of the time. Catherine Morland is a rather normal girl who loves her books a little too much. When a handsome friend and his sister invite her to their Abbey for a visit, Catherine’s wild imagination makes the most of the things that go bump in the night. I thought Austen did a great job (much like (except not at all like) Neil Gaiman in his short story Forbidden Brides of the Faceless Slaves in the Secret House of the Night of Dread Desire (review)) of taking classic Gothic themes and flipping them on their heads and creating something fun and new.

I particularly liked the relationship between Catherine and Henry — their witty banter was very well done and I could see why they were attracted to each other. I also loved that Catherine learned the value of not judging a first impression — learning that people’s character is revealed slowly and that people’s small actions may be showing what lives in their inner soul.

Positives: Really charming overall. I also loved that Austen had a relationship with the reader, mentioning little asides. It felt like a friend telling a story over coffee.

Negatives: Catherine could be a little weak at times, especially in the beginning. But she grows throughout the novel and is a fairly strong heroine at the end.

Other books I’ve read by Jane Austen:
Emma
Lady Susan
Mansfield Park (review)
Persuasion
Pride and Prejudice
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, with Seth Graham Green (review)
Sense and Sensibility

Other blogger opinions:

Age 30+…a Lifetime of Books: “She wrote this story as if she were telling it to a friend, occasionally making comments directly to the reader.  I really enjoyed that!”

The Literary Omnivore: “If you haven’t read Austen, the short Northanger Abbey would be a great place to start.”

Erin Reads: “ I liked the characters, but I was not so invested in their fates that I was unable to tear myself from the page.”

January 3, 2011

Book Review: #1 – A Damsel in Distress by PG Wodehouse

A new year of reading has begun! Changing the format of my reviews ever so slightly. Let me know if you like the change!

A Damsel in Distress by PG Wodehouse

Source: DailyLit.com
Finished: 1/2/11
Rating: 7 out of 10
Publisher: Overlook Press
Pages: 288
Originally Published: 1919

Synopsis (from the back of the book): Respectable George Bevan is minding his own business, zooming down the street in a taxi, when out of nowhere, lovely Maud Marsh jumps into the car with him, begging for his help. As George recovers from his shock, Maud’s sad plight comes to light. She is desperate to escape her aunt’s meddlesome ways and reunite with the man she loves. George is moved by Maud’s tragic tale and chivalrously offers to aid the hapless damsel. Mistaken identities, hilarious run-ins with high-tempered relatives, and all manner of shenanigans come George’s way before we can reach the exciting conclusion of this wacky romantic comedy.

Overall Impression: Wodehouse never gets old for me. I love the style of his writing (witty), the mis-adventures his charactures endure (zany and madcap), and how everyone ends up happy in the end (uh, happily). A Damsel in Distress is another delightful comedy of errors, with mistaken identities, crazy relatives, love-sick young people, and one butter-lovin’ fat man. Mix it all together and you have a delicious romp through the British countryside. I do prefer the Jeeves and Wooster stories to Wodehouse’s standalones, but nonetheless—this was a fun read and is classic Wodehouse.

Positives: Dashing, delicous, delightful!

Negatives: Not the best Wodehouse, but still good.

ExtrasPG Wodehouse resource guide, DailyLit.com—Read a Damsel in Distress for free!

Other books I’ve read by PG Wodehouse: The Inimitable Jeeves (review), Jeeves in the Morning (review), A Gentleman of Leisure (review), My Man Jeeves, Bertie Wooster Sees it Through, Do Butlers Burgle Banks?, Code of the Woosters, Jeeves and the Tie that Binds, Girls Pearls and Monty Bodkin

Other blogger opinions:

Violet Crush: “Although I didn’t laugh out loud at everything, I did have a smile on my face throughout.”

December 29, 2010

#85 – Little Brother by Cory Doctorow

Little Brother by Cory Doctorow

Read: based on the recommendation of Raych at books i done read, but it sealed the deal when I found I could read it for free on DailyLit.com. (Tor Teen, 384 pages, originally published April 2008)

Rating: 5 out of 10 (finished 12/7/10)

Synopsis: Seventeen-year-old techno-geek “w1n5t0n” (aka Marcus) bypasses the school’s gait-recognition system by placing pebbles in his shoes, chats secretly with friends on his IMParanoid messaging program, and routinely evades school security with his laptop, cell, WifFnder, and ingenuity. While skipping school, Markus is caught near the site of a terrorist attack on San Francisco and held by the Department of Homeland Security for six days of intensive interrogation. After his release, he vows to use his skills to fight back against an increasingly frightening system of surveillance. Obvious parallels to Orwellian warnings and post-9/11 policies, such as the Patriot Act, will provide opportunity for classroom discussion and raise questions about our enthusiasm for technology, who monitors our school library collections, and how we contribute to our own lack of privacy.

Overall Impression: I really liked this one when it started out, but the more I got into it, the less I enjoyed it. I realized that I prefer books that are subtle in their morals. Instead, Doctorow sort of takes the moral of the story and beats you over the head with it, Guantanamo-style. He waterboards you with the moral, if you will.

Still, I thought the technology of the book was fun and interesting. It got a little lengthy in bits, but the nerd in me thought it was sort of cool. I like the idea of a kid being way smarter than the adults around him, and starting a revolution to make sure the man wasn’t keeping them down. (“Damn the man! Save the empire!”) Problem was, everyone who was bad was a little too bad, everyone who was good was a little to sexy, and everyone who was clueless was utterly ridiculous. This book could have done with a lot more gray area — it would be closer to being like the real world.

Pros: Interesting plot idea (especially post-9/11) and a good look into the possible future of technology.

Cons: HEAVY-HANDED. WHA-BAM.

Extras: Doctorow’s website where you can download Little Brother for free (!!) and Doctorow on Twitter

Other blogger opinions:

books i done read: “And despite all the pauses for explainyness Little Brother barrels along at a surprising clip, and it is stressful and terrifying and funny and sweet and very, very smart.”

Fyrefly Books: “Little Brother is as effective of a coming-of-age story as it is a technogeek-rebellion-political-commentary, and where it really wins is by so effortlessly merging the two together.”

Rhapsody in Books: “…only one other negative aspect comes to mind: The Government villains are a little too bad to be believable, even by someone as jaded as I am.”

Other books I’ve read by Cory Doctorow: none

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 784 other followers